0121 448 4776

4.7

★★★★★

Clutch

Free resource. No email needed.

The 9 step rebrand audit.

Before you pay anyone to redesign your logo, find out what’s actually wrong. Most businesses that think they need a new look really need to agree what they’re saying. This audit shows you which one you are.

Work through the steps in order. Each one builds on the last.

The 9 steps

Before you start

What you’ll need

Gather these first. It’s the slowest part, and it’s worth doing properly.

  • Your messaging. Positioning, value proposition, tone of voice, anything written down about who you are.
  • Your brand assets. Logo files, colours, fonts, templates, brand guidelines if you have them.
  • Your sales material. The pitch deck, recent proposals, email signatures, event stands.
  • Your website and its numbers. Access to your analytics, and a list of recent enquiries.
  • Your proof. Case studies, testimonials, reviews, awards.
  • People to ask. Five or six customers, and a handful of people from across your team.

The 9 steps

1 Write down what your brand is for

Answer three questions in a sentence each:

  • Who do you serve?
  • What do you do for them?
  • Why should they choose you over the alternatives?

Then ask your leadership team to do the same, separately. Compare the answers.

What you’re looking for

If the answers don’t match, stop here. That’s the real problem, and a new logo won’t fix it. Everything after this step gets measured against these answers, so they need to be agreed first.

2 Put everything in one place

Lay out everything your brand appears on. Your website, the deck, a few proposals, your LinkedIn page, email signatures, stationery, anything from events.

What you’re looking for

How much there is, and how much of it was made by different people at different times. Most businesses are surprised by both.

3 Check it all tells the same story

Look at it side by side. Not just the colours and fonts. Read it.

  • Does every piece describe what you do in the same way?
  • Does it make the same promise?
  • Would a buyer who saw the deck, then the website, then a proposal think they were dealing with the same business?

What you’re looking for

The gaps between versions. Every gap is a place where a buyer has to guess which one is true.

4 See what your website numbers are telling you

Your website is where most buyers check you out before they get in touch. Look at:

  • Who’s arriving. Are they the kind of businesses you want to work with?
  • Where from. If most of your traffic comes from one or two sources, you’re exposed if those change.
  • What they do. Which pages do people leave from? Which ones lead to an enquiry?
  • What comes in. Are the enquiries the right ones, or does your team spend the week filtering them out?

What you’re looking for

Whether your brand is attracting the buyers you want, or just attracting buyers.

5 Ask your customers

Pick five or six customers you’d like more of. Ask them:

  • Why did you choose us?
  • How would you describe what we do to a colleague?
  • Who else did you consider?
  • What nearly stopped you buying?
  • What would you miss if we disappeared?
  • Sum us up in four words.

What you’re looking for

The words they use. Your customers often describe your value better than your own website does, and their language is what future buyers will recognise.

6 Ask your team

Ask people from sales, delivery and leadership:

  • How would you describe what we do?
  • What do you say in the first five minutes of a sales call?
  • Where do prospects get confused?
  • What do we promise that we find hard to deliver?
  • If you could change one thing about how we present ourselves, what would it be?

What you’re looking for

Where your team’s version differs from the written one, and from what customers said. The sales team’s answers are usually the most honest.

7 Ask AI what it says about you

Buyers now ask AI tools about businesses before they ever visit a website. Try ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, Perplexity and Google’s AI answers. Ask:

  • “What does [your business] do?”
  • “Who are the best [your category] businesses in [your city or sector]?”
  • “Compare [your business] with [a competitor].”

Write down what each one says, whether it recommends you, and which sources it mentions.

What you’re looking for

Whether AI describes you the way you’d describe yourself. If it gets you wrong, or doesn’t mention you at all, it’s usually because your own story isn’t clear or consistent enough for it to repeat. That’s exactly what steps 1 to 3 will have shown.

8 Look at who you’re up against

Pick three competitors. Read their websites the way a buyer would, and ask the AI tools about them too.

  • How do they describe what they do?
  • Where do you all sound the same?
  • What do they say that you could say better, or that you’d never say?

What you’re looking for

The space nobody else is claiming. If you swapped your logo for a competitor’s, would anyone notice? If not, the problem isn’t the logo.

9 Decide what to keep, change and drop

Take everything you’ve learned and sort it into three lists:

  • Keep. What’s working, what customers recognise, and what’s earned you a reputation. Recognition is valuable, so don’t throw it away without a reason.
  • Change. What’s right in spirit but inconsistent, dated or unclear.
  • Drop. What no longer fits who you serve or what you do.

Then, before anything changes, write down where you are today, so you can tell whether the rebrand worked:

  • How many enquiries you get, and how many are the right ones.
  • How your website converts.
  • How AI tools describe you.
  • How customers describe you. Ask the step 5 questions again six months after launch and compare.

What you’re looking for

A clear answer to whether you need a full rebrand, a refresh, or just to agree what you’re saying.

What the audit usually shows

It’s rarely the logo.

A logo is how you’re recognised. What builds trust is saying the same thing, clearly, everywhere. Most audits show the look is less of a problem than the message. The business has grown, the story hasn’t caught up, and everyone is telling a slightly different version of it.

That’s good news. It’s usually quicker and cheaper to fix than a full rebrand.

Questions

Do I need a rebrand or a refresh?

If the audit shows your story is right but your look is dated, you probably need a refresh. If it shows people are confused about what you do, or you’ve outgrown who you serve, the thinking needs to change first, then the look.

Can we do this ourselves?

Yes, that’s why it’s free. Most teams can gather and ask. The hard part is step 9: getting everyone with a stake in it to agree what to keep and what to change.

Why include AI?

Because buyers use it. If AI tools can’t describe you clearly, buyers get a vague version of you before they reach your website, and often a version that sounds like everyone else.

Found more questions than answers?

That’s normal. Spotting the gaps is the easy part. Getting your team to agree what to do about them is what our strategy workshop is for. One day, your team in a room, and a direction everyone has agreed to by the time you leave.